The Continued Importance of Legal Advice in Respect of Matrimonial Finances

The current law

The Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 currently governs and helps determine how financial assets are split upon divorce in England and Wales but at 50 years old is that law still relevant to today’s modern society? 

A very brief history

The first law governing divorce was the Matrimonial Causes Act of 1857 which created a divorce procedure which went through the court system alone. There have since been many amendments over the years to reflect societal changes and views and in fact, the process of divorce itself was simplified by The Divorce, Dissolution and Separation Act 2020 which came into force on 6th April 2022, but what of the financial aspects of divorce?

But what of matrimonial Finances?

It is reported that the Government is to review the 1973 Matrimonial Causes Act as critics state that it is uncertain and unpredictable and has no clear guidance as to how assets should be divided. The current system has been developed by case law and enables judges the discretion to make different awards and allows for regional variations in divorce settlements. It is partly due to this that London is seen as an attractive prospect for wealthy divorcing couples due to its reputation for giving generous financial awards to ex-wives. A particularly large settlement (more than £500 million) that illustrates this is the 2021 ruling in the High Court between the billionaire ruler of Dubai and his estranged wife. 

Complexities of finances

Over the years a couple’s finances inevitably become weaved together and there is no obvious or easy solution upon the breakdown of the marriage as to how the assets should be divided. As the law currently stands there is no clear guidance on issues such as spousal maintenance and this can lead to protracted arguments and an already tense situation becoming worse. However, a one size fits all solution would also surely not work as there are so many factors to be considered in each relationship breakdown and what works for one couple may leave one party in another couple without sufficient means. 

How can we help you now?

Disclosure

Within any financial matters, there is an ongoing duty for both parties to be fully open and honest in relation to their assets and financial position. We can assist in ensuring that you gather together all of the correct financial information (disclosure) and if necessary can assist in completing a Form E setting out your full financial circumstances. 

We appreciate that people’s circumstances are different and we are able to assist each individual with what is best for their needs whether that be simply obtaining bank statements or assisting in getting a property or business valuation. 

Alternative dispute resolution 

Alternatives to court proceedings can be cost-effective and quicker and include negotiation, mediation and arbitration. 

Mediation is a way to resolve issues related to children or finances with the help of an independent third party. We are able to refer you to mediation and to advise you throughout the mediation process and draft any agreement into an order.  

Arbitration involves the parties appointing an independent neutral arbitrator to listen to the evidence and make a decision as to how the matter in dispute should be settled. We are able to assist with the arbitration process by instructing the correct people and drafting the relevant papers and recently assisted in arbitration in a matter where court proceedings in respect of financial matters were ongoing but with significant delays in the court.  The parties agreed to attempt arbitration which progressed in much the same manner as a court hearing would but on a more informal basis. Ultimately by using arbitration the parties’ matter was resolved much more quickly than the court process allows saving both parties money and allowing them to move on with their lives in a timely manner. 

Even if matters progress to the stage of court proceedings ADR can still be used to help reach an agreement and most certainly negotiations should continue throughout. 

Prenuptial agreements

A prenuptial agreement is entered into before marriage and sets out what belongs to which party after divorce and can be a good way to protect, amongst other things, assets and inheritance.

Such agreements are not currently legally binding in the UK but have been recognised since the Supreme Court case of Radmacher in 2010. 

As matters stand a prenuptial agreement is more likely to be recognised if both parties have obtained independent legal advice, there has been full disclosure of both parties’ assets and the agreement is freely entered into. 

Within the Government review experts are calling for prenuptial agreements to be put on a more formal basis which would be beneficial to many, creating certainty going forwards and helping to reduce arguments upon separation. 

It would however remain vital that independent legal advice was obtained and any agreement drawn up is done fairly and with the full consent of both parties. 

Consent orders

A consent order is an order that settles financial matters between the parties upon the breakdown of a marriage or civil partnership. It is vital that the order is drafted correctly and includes all aspects of the agreement reached between the parties as once it is approved by the court it cannot be amended. 

Such orders can be reached through negotiations, mediation or court proceedings or the parties may already agree and simply want assistance in turning that agreement into an order.

The drafting of a consent order can become complex as it deals with so many aspects of the parties’ lives and getting the wording correct is vital. 

Court proceedings

If no agreement can be reached an application can be made to the court and this can, in fact, mean that there is a focus on the process, a timetable is put in place and an end goal is worked towards with the assistance of the court. At all stages, throughout the court process, the parties are given the opportunity to agree on a settlement and it would only be at a final hearing that an order would be enforced upon them. Court proceedings can be distressing and complex for those representing themselves and the assistance of a solicitor can help ease the burden. 

How we can continue to help you

There is no doubt that the Matrimonial Causes Act, at 50 years old may not remain fit for purpose and a review would be welcomed to simplify the procedures and set out clear guidance for people seeking a financial settlement. The outcome of the review will no doubt be eagerly awaited. 

However, the need for good, clear legal advice will remain vital whether that be to assist in setting out intentions prior to marriage or assisting in putting any agreement into a formal document and ensuring a fair outcome for both parties.

Have any questions?

If you would like further advice regarding matrimonial finances or any other family matter please contact us on 0121 355 8885 or email our family law team at sarahshenton@nlegal.co.uk. 

Kimberley Kong | N Legal Solicitors Sutton Coldfield

Kimberley Kong

I am the Director of N Legal Solicitors which was established on 1st November 2000. Understanding our clients and their business is the cornerstone of our success.